Economy

The Complex Intersection of IVF, Religion, and Legal Definitions of Embryos

Published June 5, 2024

For Amanda and Jeff Walker, the journey to parenthood was marked by trials of infertility. In their quest to have a child, they turned to in vitro fertilization (IVF), a decision that ultimately brought them joy in the form of a baby. The process, however, yielded additional embryos, presenting the Walkers with a complex moral and ethical dilemma. They were left grappling with the question of what to do with these potential lives, an issue that intimately intertwines with their Christian beliefs and the recent judicial ruling that legally classifies embryos as children.

The Legal and Moral Quandary of Unused Embryos

The legal classification of embryos has profound implications, reaching into the realms of family planning and religious conviction. When a court deems embryos as children, it raises significant questions for those with surplus embryos from IVF procedures. Should these embryos be preserved indefinitely, donated to science, offered to other couples, or disposed of? For devout Christians like the Walkers, these decisions are far from trivial, straddling the line between personal beliefs and legal considerations.

Embryo Adoption: A Viable Option

Tori and Sam Earle exemplify a different approach to the same conundrum. They 'adopted' an embryo that had been frozen for over two decades. This embryo, originally created by another couple, had remained in limbo until the Earles decided to give it a chance at life. Their decision to adopt sheds light on an alternative path for unused embryos, one that aligns with their Christian doctrine and the growing concept of embryo 'adoption.'

IVF, Ethics, Religion